Israel-Diaspora Relations

Managing the Growing Challenges to Jewish Cohesion

 

JPPI’s 2023 Jewish World Dialogue examined the growing polarization and uncivil discourse within Israel and Jewish communities worldwide – especially in regard to Israeli government policies affecting religious pluralism in Israel, the balance of power between the Israeli judiciary and the other branches of government, and the administered/occupied territories (Judea and Samaria, aka the West Bank) post-l967.

By: Dr. Shlomo Fischer, Dr. John Ruskay

Project Coordinator: Jonathan Siedel

Editor: Barry Geltman

Managing the Growing Challenges to Jewish Cohesion
Shutterstock

Managing the Growing Challenges to Jewish Cohesion

 

1. Benson Strategy Services, JFNA Community Understanding Survey, Nov. 21, 2023.

2. Out of those, because of various technical difficulties, only 176 participants completed the online survey. The numbers we cite are taken from the online survey, however the quotes and the qualitative analysis and conclusions are based upon the entire participant pool.

3. J Street was the clear outlier in age with 92% 65+ and everyone over 46.

4. Including non-North American participants. South Africa was predominately Orthodox yet liberal.

5. Most Germans did not think Israel was the most polarizing subject. Almost all J Street participants felt it was.

6. Orthodox respondents too, indicated that Israel was not as polarizing.

7. Both quotes were taken verbatim from the anonymous questionnaire.

8. Haaretz, July 17, 2023.

9. The only group of whom the majority of participants (by 1) experienced a decrease in discussions was the Council of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations.

10. The Cleveland Federation was the only group in which more participants said that they avoid such conversations than those who said that they seek them out.

11. Yehonatan Lis, The Knesset Constitutional Committee Discussed the Wexner Foundation; MK Karei: It acts so as to penetrate poison.” Haaretz, July 15, 2020. Moran Azulai, The New Israel Fund: Netanyahu has Crossed a Red Line in his Incitement Against Us.” Ynet, April 3, 2018. (See box with Netanyahu’s Facebook post).

12. See John Ruskay, “Israel Advocacy and Israel Education,” E-Jewish Philanthropy, April 21, 2021.

PreviousNext